There are various factors that led to the Great Depression, but when America's economy was already weak and vulnerable, the gold standard simply led to more destruction.
The gold standard before 1931 was used to allow currencies to place a value on their currency relative to a set standard. This allowed people to know the worth of their money no mater what currency they possessed. However, for many countries who were low on gold, the pressure to keep up with the gold standard was building up. Some suggest that abandoning the gold standard made nations one step closer to recovering from the depression. These countries would have to tighten their credit in fear that if they didn't they would have to default on the exchange rate. If a country didn't cut back on their spending, people holding their notes would exchange their notes for gold worrying that inflation would devalue the notes. However, if people panicked, which many did, and started turning in their dollars for gold, the gold reserves would be exhausted. If the reserve levels were low, the nations couldn't issue as much currency. For many countries, it was a lot easier to abandon the gold standard and to set the value of the currency based on their own system. In September of 1931, Britain defaulted on its gold payments to foreigners and abandoned the gold standard. This followed up with a chain reaction from 24 other countries.
Because Britain pulled out of the gold standard, the world economy became still. America at this time had already been raising high tariffs and enacting protective policies which further clogged the flow of money. This feeling of fear from central Europe and Britain was quickly reaching the United States. When the government's budget was running low because of all the services it was providing, banks, depositors, and investors were quick to trade in their cash for gold. With their gold, they would simply hoard it and hold on to it without making new investments or purchases. Just like we discussed in class when the 2% of the population that were in control of 26% of the wealth stopped purchasing and circulating their money, no one else was there to make up the gap. Much like the 2% that sold their stocks during a time of panic, the wealthy investors and depositors were quick to exchange their paper money for gold to hold on to what they were left with.
It's interesting to see how a weak economy can be so easily and instantly affected by a sudden trigger. When one person starts to panic and sell their stock or exchange their money for gold, it simply becomes a chain reaction that just goes downhill. Britain's departure of gold led to 24 other countries abandoning the gold standard. In a time of depression, people went from having a nice house, car, and a full stomach one day to absolutely nothing the next day. This is all a result of how quickly fear is able to take over people's minds and how easily one trigger can spark an entire disaster.
Sources:
http://www.nber.org/chapters/c11482.pdf
Freedom from Fear, David Kennedy
http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2011-12-12/the-gold-standard-and-the-great-depression-echoes
First a clarification question. What is the "y" axis of your graph displaying? Secondly, you say that Britain's leaving the gold standard caused a chain reaction, why didn't Japan's abandonment of the gold standard cause a chain reaction? I see your point about the gold standard being bad for business, especially since inflation (caused by the removal of the gold standard) made it easier to pay off debts.
ReplyDeleteSources:
http://www.nber.org/chapters/c11482.pdf
http://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/fdr-takes-united-states-off-gold-standard
I like how you included the graph it helps visualize the effects of it. How do you think the worlds economy would have changed if Britain pulled out of the gold standard later? How do you think the it would have been similar?
ReplyDeletehttp://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/GoldStandard.html
The "y" axis I believe is meant to show the production and prices although the graph itself does not specify how the unit of measurement. This graph was only attached to provide a very broad sense of how the gold standard affected a country's economy. If Britain had pulled out later, I believe it probably would have had an even worse affect. By that time, more countries would have probably been pressured by the gold standard and more of them would have followed suit with Britain's departure of gold. However, either way, whether it be sooner or later, it was inevitable that there was going to be some trigger point where the economy came to a stand still because of the fragility of the economies.
ReplyDeletehttps://michaelkitson.files.wordpress.com/2013/02/kitson-gold-standard-june-2012.pdf
Was there an alternative that Britain and the other countries that followed it off the gold standard used to value their currency? I'm a little confused about how countries could adjust the value of their currency if there was nothing to compare it against. I believe that today, most currencies are valued against the dollar, but the US isn't on the gold standard anymore either.
ReplyDeleteWas there an alternative that Britain and the other countries that followed it off the gold standard used to value their currency? I'm a little confused about how countries could adjust the value of their currency if there was nothing to compare it against. I believe that today, most currencies are valued against the dollar, but the US isn't on the gold standard anymore either.
ReplyDelete